architectural power

#project



An important thing to remember is that the main objective of this project is a political one – to help define contemporary political contours insomuch that a political reorientation within architectural thought becomes possible. In order to do so, however, we cannot simply stay within the limited discipline of architecture, let alone the constricts of the architectural project, nor the standard assembly of political theory. There is a (relatively) new field of agency and dynamic reality which first must be understood: we must examine the long extending tendons of cybernetics, the set of technical, ideological and epistemic conditions which have underwritten the emergence of digital culture as much as they have rewritten the definitions of the human, their systems of relations and production, and the environments which contain and elude them. Specifically, the architectural focus of the political is of prime relevance, as a radical conception of system politics instantiates itself in the architectural rather than the ceremonial. The Invisible Committee writes, “power resides in the infrastructures of this world. Contemporary power is now of an architectural and impersonal, and not a representative or personal, nature.” Examining the political through architecture is not only reviewing the connection between disciplines, but opening up architectural production and operation as a central site of political power in the age of derivative control.

A quick summary of the keywords involved (Cybernetics, Politics, Architecture) might be shuffled in any number of ways, as their relation is non-linear, an aspect which makes the nexus of themes intriguing to engage with and complicated to explain in a normative causal manner. And yet, explained it must be while refraining from engaging in a causal sequence which is not there, and yet still balancing the interactions and focuses of Architecture, Cybernetics, Politics. The following research will thus not be a procession of previous research into unturned stone into archival material into conclusion. A state of the research- by way of clarifying how cybernetics has been culturally disentangled so far, how architecture has addressed cybernetic concepts in its theorization and practice, how political theory has collided with both architecture and cybernetics - is necessarily a cornerstone in each section of the research. However, it cannot be adequately isolated within a literature review or grounding section as might be traditionally attempted. Instead, there will be a loose but recursive structure in which three sections- each containing three chapters - overlap with one other, passing codas of objects and discourses among themselves.





I. This is not the Point
Chapter I (This is not the Point) addresses the various ways that cybernetics has been examined as an epistemological framework within cultural studies, science and technology studies, and media studies. Select sources addressing the technological history of cybernetics in Architecture are also addressed along overlapping research which looked into the effect of cybernetics within a political reading of architectural organizations. The goal of this section is to establish the foundational arguments inherited from others and distinguish the focus of the project.

II. New Binary Drop

Chapter II(New Binary Drop) addresses the approach of cybernetics and new invocations of cybernetic concepts in architecture, specifically examining the intellectual arguments made in order to dissolve specific binaries (human vs. technology, vitalism vs. mechanism, etc.) and how these methods ignore the reproduction of other binaries (top-down vs. bottom-up, material vs. ideology, techno-positive vs. techno-phobic) which ultimately corrupt the use of said cybernetic concepts.

III. Control Society and its Non-Forms

Chapter III (Control and Derivative Agency) addresses the control society, how Deleuze and Michael Hardt each approach the control society and its relation to technologies and space, and how cybernetics has affected the diffusion of control society in the smart city arguments of many contemporary urbanists. Furthermore, the concept of derivative agency is introduced, representing the manner in which control can take place within a system of networks without direct causation, following from the political-medial work of Galloway with Protocol and The Exploit. 

IV. Liberal Organization

Chapter IV (Liberal Organization) examines Reinhold Martin’s research on “organizational complexes” and its relations to the 20thcentury use of cybernetics as a technique for controlling space and interaction within liberal-democracy. This chapter will introduce the historical tensions within cybernetics concerning the liberal subject and will show the manner in which cybernetics has been attempted to be understood in architecture as a set of operations acting within traditional 20th century political affordances.

V. Cultural Resonances
Chapter V (Cultural Resonances) uses Felicity D Scott’s work on the exchange of cultural ideas between private and public institutions (university labs, architectural offices, think tanks) and the post-war counterculture to examine the ways in which cybernetic concepts were packaged and passed between various actors. This chapter will introduce second-order cybernetics and relate it with Scott’s research, showing how cybernetics has impacted the socio-technical discussions within a wide set of cultural actors.
VI. Neo-Liberalisms

Chapter VI (Neoliberalisms) uses the critical theory research of Douglas Spencer on the historical and ongoing relationship between cybernetics and neoliberal practices in architecture. Spencer’s Marxist reading of political economy and the built environment approach cybernetics as a superstructural extension of ideology, and his critical solutions return to mid-century Marxist readings of architecture potential, rather than reorienting to novel political affordances. Additional criticism of neoliberal practices in architecture and urban design from Neil Brenner and Erik Swyngedouw will be used to further contextualize Marxist attempts to criticize the systems-oriented behavior of neoliberalism. This chapter will additionally introduce the systems concept of Autopoiesis (ala Varela and Maturana), as well as the social theories of Niklas Luhmann and their effect in architectural theory and design, particularly in Patrik Schumacher’s The Autopoiesis of Architecture.



VII. Emerging Realisms

Chapter VII (Emerging Realisms) reflects on the conceptual difficulties of architectural research to appropriately orient itself to cybernetics and digital culture politically. This chapter introduces a more in-depth discussion of the political theory of Tiqqun, which centers “the cybernetic hypothesis” as a paradigmatic shift in political affordance and agential formation. Furthermore, this chapter uses the cybernetic and anti-capitalist research of Mark Fisher to examine cybernetic ideology as a type of emerging realism. Political and social theory will be architecturally situated via the examination of the recently renovated Battersea Power Station and Nine Elms district in London and the urban analysis theories, practices and softwares of Space Syntax.
VIII. Political Paradigm

Chapter VIII (Political Paradigm) contextualizes political paradigmatic shifts as they relate to agency and technology, examining the political theories from Chantal Mouffe and Ernesto Laclau to describe the previous transition into the modern era of political affordance (the democratic revolution) and to further contextualize the ongoing shifts as described by Tiqqun (The Cybernetic Hypothesis), Gilles Deleuze (Postscript on the Society of Control), Alexander Galloway & Eugene Thacker (The Exploit), and Donna Harraway (“A Manifesto for Cyborgs”). The shifts in political paradigm will be architecturally situated via the examination of the “Born Digital” collection at the Canadian Centre of Architecture archives in Montreal.

IX. Architectural Power

Chapter IX (Architectural Power) further develops the concept of architectural and infrastructural power via the theories of infrastructural studies and The Invisible Committee, and reflects on how architectural power is enacted and how it might be decayed. Furthermore, this chapter will situate architectural spaces that are oriented toward cybernetic control and those that engage in modes of resistance to the cybernetic hypothesis. A synthesis will be presented as to how architecture can be situated within a new conception of political affordance, and address potentials in architectural production, examining...