Formalizing Relations: Space Syntax and the Cybernetic Hypothesis
#research“Examining computation, its histories and materialities, offers a variety of ends – fugues of innovation, gateways to speculation, blind navel gazing and glimpses of situated and operative knowledge. In the architectural context, the uncovering of computation via its uneven trajectories is related to the almost ubiquitous digitization of representative, analytic, formal and management processes. Unfolding the development of computational technologies through their specifications, their technical novelty, through the universal problems which they continue to orient themselves against, continues to be relevant within the expanding sites of research in architectural faculties – departments far more stable in their rationalization and funding than those which might critically appraise them. Computational histories in architectural research have unveiled post-war working atmospheres which first engaged in the algorithmic management of spatial planning,[1] they reveal the non-linearity and medial tensions of competing software developments which congealed into modern spatial data,[2] and they have interrogated the emergence of digital differences in the media philosophy of architectural production.[3] The presiding history of the digital in Architecture is technical and academic, engaged with the procession of objects produced and the socio-historical conditions of their development – the timeline is a complex network of institutions and practitioners as points in a celebratory media archaeology and largely, in any useful definition, apolitical.”
“A critical historiography of computation’s development and pan-disciplinary influence since the flood of algorithmic devices after the second world war finds itself in the space between material and ideological analysis, taking up the emergent dominance of concepts championed by systems science and cybernetics beginning in the 1940s. Media theorist Claus Pias has described the concepts of cybernetics (information, feedback, autopoetics, etc.) as an epistemology which becomes activated when introduced within disciplines, inducing each to reformulate their most fundamental forms of action and knowledge.[4] This epistemology was heralded as the end of philosophy by Martin Heiddeger and, building on Heidegger’s works, described by media philosopher Yuk Hui as the conquest of the scientific method in its attempt to “render philosophical reflections redundant”, insomuch that operable and dynamic systems – computing systems – determine the supremacy of a type of information and a type of relation among agencies.[5] Radically, this historically coordinated and increasingly dominant view to the world can be viewed as a political metamorphosis. French political theory collective Tiqqun has positioned the cybernetic hypothesis as the unrolling of a new field of political affordance, one which engages in the programmability of biological, physical and social systems, replacing the previous liberal hypothesis and its humanist enlightenment foundations.[6] Tiqqun examines the formation of these conditions as a “genealogy of imperial government,” which stretches among disciplinary sites and technologies, emerging through a tangle of material and ideological effects.[7]”
...“Space Syntax is a theory and methodology of describing, calculating and analyzing space which undergirds: (a) the UCL Space Syntax Laboratory (SSL) established in 1972 through EPSRC funding[8]; (b) the Space Syntax Limited urban analysis consultancy company established in 1989; (c) the biannual Space Syntax Symposia series beginning in 1997 to disseminate research and technology development. While the methods have poured out from the laboratory into a world of plug-ins, stand-alone softwares like DepthMapX, and new media experiments which build on Space Syntax’s foundations, the focus here will be on the foundational theories which formalize space into an object of computation.
The Social Logic of Space, Bill Hillier and Julienne Hanson’s 1984 capstone to research at the UCL laboratory, focuses on theorizing space as an autonomous element which is constitutive rather than derivative of society. As they describe, an applied theory of theory of space must establish a “descriptive autonomy,” while also accounting for wide variations in morphological type (unorganized to highly organized) and the different manners of fitting within the social system.[9] As such, the 1970s and 80s research of Hillier, Hanson, Adrian Leaman, Paul Stanstall, Michael Bedford and others in the SSL is an attempt to establish space as an empirical point of sociological, anthropological and urban study. They approach space as structuralists, building a piece-meal logic from the writings of Claude Levi-Strauss, Émile Durkheim and Jean Piaget, and attempting to decode the structural rule-sets which determine the layout of human settlements.[10] Space Syntax as a theory is conceptually derived from their assumed primacy of syntax above semantics – structural relations above meaning – as the observable and generating factor of social spaces.[11]”
“The formalization of spatial relations within Space Syntax contribute genealogically to the disciplinary establishment of the cybernetic hypothesis within architectural and urban design. The distillation of space into nodes of computation, especially in the abstraction and dislocation of data, marks one of Katherine Hayles’ central performances of twentieth century cybernetics: the negation of the body.[12] Hayles also describes the tactic of separating empirical and non-empirical characteristics, claiming to recognize the value of the immeasurable and then creating technical models in which only the measurable can be used to evaluate any given environment.
Director of Space Syntax Limited, Tim Stonor, has placed the utility of Space Syntax in the analysis of connections between populations and locations, leading to planning decisions to gird or augment human transaction: “Because all cities are about transaction between people, people coming together and trading, whether that’s social trade or economic trade.”[13] The conceptualization of all social behavior as transactional is useful in Space Syntax in the same way Claude Shannon found Information theory useful for description of communication – it leaves out the semantics and the mutable.
While never directly referring to cybernetics and only obliquely to systems sciences, the development of Space Syntax contributes to the evolution of the cybernetic hypothesis. As Tiqqun describe, the “cybernetic gesture asserts itself by a negation of everything that escapes regulation, of all the lines of escape that save existence in the interstices of the norm and its apparatuses…”[14] While the methods of abstraction and prediction from Space Syntax are a digital world apart from contemporary artificial intelligence, they both are technological milieus which thrive in the statistical episteme of the cybernetic and have worryingly taken over the discourse of persuasion. Even more concerningly, the trend of AI-based analysis excitingly profits from retrieving the decades of partially verifiable Space Syntax data produced since the 1970s.
The cybernetic hypothesis tracks a world-view which is based on assumptions of feedback and available information, a world-view which presupposes a dynamic equilibrium of set relations, and whose most significant influences become the seemingly apparent and uncontestable – simple shades of green and red within an urban grid. However, disciplinary genealogies of the cybernetic hypothesis are not meant as lamentations, but as important avenues for understanding the stakes in challenging the unspoken assumptions of technology and its cultures of development. Alternative modes of rationality and situated knowledge, historical and incipient, are available and must be made imaginable and operative.”
Director of Space Syntax Limited, Tim Stonor, has placed the utility of Space Syntax in the analysis of connections between populations and locations, leading to planning decisions to gird or augment human transaction: “Because all cities are about transaction between people, people coming together and trading, whether that’s social trade or economic trade.”[13] The conceptualization of all social behavior as transactional is useful in Space Syntax in the same way Claude Shannon found Information theory useful for description of communication – it leaves out the semantics and the mutable.
While never directly referring to cybernetics and only obliquely to systems sciences, the development of Space Syntax contributes to the evolution of the cybernetic hypothesis. As Tiqqun describe, the “cybernetic gesture asserts itself by a negation of everything that escapes regulation, of all the lines of escape that save existence in the interstices of the norm and its apparatuses…”[14] While the methods of abstraction and prediction from Space Syntax are a digital world apart from contemporary artificial intelligence, they both are technological milieus which thrive in the statistical episteme of the cybernetic and have worryingly taken over the discourse of persuasion. Even more concerningly, the trend of AI-based analysis excitingly profits from retrieving the decades of partially verifiable Space Syntax data produced since the 1970s.
The cybernetic hypothesis tracks a world-view which is based on assumptions of feedback and available information, a world-view which presupposes a dynamic equilibrium of set relations, and whose most significant influences become the seemingly apparent and uncontestable – simple shades of green and red within an urban grid. However, disciplinary genealogies of the cybernetic hypothesis are not meant as lamentations, but as important avenues for understanding the stakes in challenging the unspoken assumptions of technology and its cultures of development. Alternative modes of rationality and situated knowledge, historical and incipient, are available and must be made imaginable and operative.”
[1] Grayson Bailey & Nathalie Bredella, “Is That a Computer Program? Carl Steinitz on the Early Years of harvard’s Laboratory for comput Graphics and Spatial Analysis,” in Dimensions Journal of Architectural Knowledge 7 (2025), 79-97.
[2] Grayson Bailey & Nathalie Bredella, “On the Fringes of SYMAP: Post-war Thematic Cartography and the politics of visualization,” in IEEE Annals of the History of Computing Special Issue: Computer Visualizations in the Sciences (to published 2027).
[3] John May, Image Signal Architecture (New York: Columbia University Press, 2019).
[4] Claus Pias, “”Hollerith ‘Feathered Crytal’”: Art Science, and Computing in the Era of Cybernetics,” in Grey Room 29 (Winter 2008), 111.
[5] Yuk Hui, “Why Cybernetics Now?” in Cybernetics for the 21st Century, vol. 1: Epistemological Reconstruction, ed. Yuk Hui (Hong Kong: Hanart Press, 2024), 12.
[6] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis (South Pasadena: Semiotext(e), 2020), 25.
[7] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis, 32.
[8] Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, the main funding body for engineering ahd physical sciences research in the United Kingdom (ukri.org).
[9] Bill Hillier & Julienne Hanson, The Social Logic of Space (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984), 5.
[10] Hillier & Hanson, The Social Logic of Space, 4 & 47.
[11] Ibid, 16
[12] Katherin Hayles, How We Became Posthuman, 7.
[13] Tim Stonor, audio transcription from the 2012 Space Syntax Company Introduction video.
[14] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis, 27.
[2] Grayson Bailey & Nathalie Bredella, “On the Fringes of SYMAP: Post-war Thematic Cartography and the politics of visualization,” in IEEE Annals of the History of Computing Special Issue: Computer Visualizations in the Sciences (to published 2027).
[3] John May, Image Signal Architecture (New York: Columbia University Press, 2019).
[4] Claus Pias, “”Hollerith ‘Feathered Crytal’”: Art Science, and Computing in the Era of Cybernetics,” in Grey Room 29 (Winter 2008), 111.
[5] Yuk Hui, “Why Cybernetics Now?” in Cybernetics for the 21st Century, vol. 1: Epistemological Reconstruction, ed. Yuk Hui (Hong Kong: Hanart Press, 2024), 12.
[6] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis (South Pasadena: Semiotext(e), 2020), 25.
[7] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis, 32.
[8] Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, the main funding body for engineering ahd physical sciences research in the United Kingdom (ukri.org).
[9] Bill Hillier & Julienne Hanson, The Social Logic of Space (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984), 5.
[10] Hillier & Hanson, The Social Logic of Space, 4 & 47.
[11] Ibid, 16
[12] Katherin Hayles, How We Became Posthuman, 7.
[13] Tim Stonor, audio transcription from the 2012 Space Syntax Company Introduction video.
[14] Tiqqun, The Cybernetic Hypothesis, 27.